Reviews

Review Details

• Review fromRyan Z

  Date: 05/25/2023

  5 stars
  Overall, my experience with Goldin Auctions was outstanding. Their exceptional customer service, expertise, transparency, and remarkable results make them the go-to choice for anyone looking to sell valuable items. I wholeheartedly recommend Goldin Auctions to anyone seeking a seamless and successful auction experience. Thank you, Goldin Auctions, for your remarkable service!

• Review fromLogan P

  Date: 05/25/2023

  5 stars

  Logan P

  Date: 05/25/2023

  I recently had a great experience of selling an item through Goldin Auctions. Their team guided me through the entire selling process, offering valuable insights and personalized assistance at every step. From the initial item evaluation and authentication to the creation of an enticing auction listing, their team demonstrated a deep understanding of the market and the best strategies to maximize the value of my item.One aspect that truly stood out was the meticulous attention to detail and accuracy. They conducted thorough research and provided comprehensive descriptions of my item, accompanied by high-quality images that showcased its unique features. Their team promptly addressed any inquiries or concerns I had, ensuring that I felt supported and informed throughout the selling process. From answering questions from interested bidders to providing regular updates on the auction's progress, as well as clear and timely communication. The bidding really ramped up and gave me a final sell price far beyond my expectations.The teams dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every interaction. They consistently go above and beyond to provide an exceptional selling/buying experience, and their commitment to transparency, accuracy, marketing efforts, and efficient processes makes them my top choice for anyone looking to get in the hobby.I recommend Goldin to anyone considering selling or buying collectible items. Truly sets the bar high in the auction industry, ensuring that sellers, like me, receive the utmost care and attention throughout the entire selling process.

  Goldin Auctions

  Date: 10/10/2023

  Hi *****,Thank you for the kind words and helping promote our business in a positive light. You are appreciated and valued. Thank you.

  Goldin Auctions

  Date: 10/10/2023

  Hi *****,Thank you for the kind words and helping promote our business in a positive light. You are appreciated and valued. Thank you.

  Goldin Auctions

  Date: 10/10/2023

  Hi *****,Thank you for the kind words and helping promote our business in a positive light. You are appreciated and valued. Thank you.

• Review fromRoss A

  Date: 05/23/2023

  1 star
  This company *****. Mailed in 20 cards to be graded and I had to contact people left and right to find out the status. They wouldnt even send me a confirmation that they got the cards and after I complained and complained they tell me my cards arent worth brought to get graded so they are sending them back. They are very slow in getting them back to me. Second, I have done my research over and over and over and according to sales history and everything they would sell well over the grading price. This company made me waste my money on shipping, insurance and everything. They dont have CLEAR terms to what they accept and reject and therefore make the consumer waste money. After researching online its typical of this company to do this, they are only interested in stuff selling for over $1k but do not make the consumers clear of that. Its a joke and now I have to pay for shipping to get them back to me after they already made me waste my money. ****, one of the cards alone I sent in has been selling for over $400 which would cover the entire grading cost for ******************************** NONE of them are worth nothing. I know my stuff and know they are completely wrong. To h*** with goldin

• Review fromAnthony S

  Date: 05/17/2023

  5 stars
  I've sold through Goldin for more than one year now. I hold them in high regard. When selling sports related items and memorabilia, no matter who you sell with, there are always some communications issues and misunderstandings, which arise from time to time. Overall, I've found Goldin most responsive and helpful in these matters. The only fault I've found is the low opening bid price of $5 in their sports card auctions. Average price of grading through PSA is $19 to $45 for standard turnaround. Due to experienced buyers taking advantage of low opening bids and low incremental increases on subsequent bids, sellers stand to lose hundreds of dollars over time in these auctions. I see this as a poor business model for that niche and one Goldin needs to address sooner than later or else, lose a significant customer base. That said, in all other areas I've found Goldin to be the most trustworthy, practical and convenient seller platform in today's market.

• Review fromDanny K

  Date: 05/10/2023

  1 star

  Danny K

  Date: 05/10/2023

  It is May 10th, and my December consignment has still not been paid out. Mid January, I emailed my consignment director *********************, and asked for it to be auctioned again because it seemed highly likely that the buyer was going to default on payment. They stated that they were certain the buyer was going to pay, and for the last 6 months have been withholding my asset. The big issue here is the significant drop in value over the last several months, so if it were auctioned again today, I would lose tens of thousands of dollars. Of course, the drop in value makes it far less likely that it will be paid for, and yet for the last 2 months they have stated they expect a wire to come in from the buyer within a few days. Do to my belief that Goldin Auctions has fraudulent intentions, I have contacted my lawyer to resolve the situation. I will be taking my business to Heritage Auctions moving forward. If other clients are having similar issues please do the community a favor and post them here.

  Goldin Auctions

  Date: 05/17/2023

  Hi ******,I am very sorry to hear about your experience with us and would love to help get this solved. I have reached out to the necessary parties involved and can assure you that I will have this matter resolved for you. Rest assured this will be a priority of mine but in the meantime, I have sent you an email and would love to discuss further what I can do to rectify this situation. Also, please feel free to contact ** anytime at ********************************* with any other concerns you may have.

• Review fromDavid J

  Date: 05/01/2023

  5 stars
  Been with this company for a little under 3 months now. Love the environment and the people. Also check out our ******* series **** of Collectibles The Goldin Touch and tell a friend.

• Review fromTyler H

  Date: 05/01/2023

  5 stars
  Was very easy to get my cards from PSA to their vault and instantly sell on Goldin. Got more than I expected for my cards. Vaulting super easy and nice to know it was safe and insured throughout the process.

• Review fromMark E

  Date: 05/01/2023

  5 stars
  I've won a few trading cards from an auction and it was a seamless process to pay and ship the items. With how easy the site is to use, I will continue to build my card collection.

• Review fromDan T

  Date: 05/01/2023

  5 stars
  Goldin has sold a few different things for me over the last few years -- a lot of cards, some video games, some jerseys, and signed basketballs. All of those experiences were efficient, and I was happy with the final prices. In the beginning, the transparency wasn't great, but they've added a lot more notifications so that I know what's going on. I hope they keep adding tools to make things easier for me.

• Review fromJacob P

  Date: 05/01/2023

  5 stars
  In my opinion, there is no better place to buy and sell collectibles right now. Goldin does all of the work for you if you're selling. If buying, they allow you to use their vault to store items that you may want to sell down the road. Great experience.